What is the McCloud Remedy?

In 2015 the government decided to change most public sector pension schemes, so that pension entitlements would be based upon career average salaries (the reformed scheme), as opposed to the final salary basis (legacy scheme).

This saw individuals being staggered onto the new scheme with those closer to retirement continuing under the original legacy scheme and those further aware from retirement moving onto the new reformed scheme.

Those moving onto the reformed scheme became less beneficial than those on the legacy scheme which created a discrimination case, under the Equalities Act 2010, based on age. The Court of appeal confirmed this case and sided with members.

 

Latest guidance on Public Sector Pensions.

In November 2024 HMRC updated and released their guidance on how the McCloud Remedy will be managed.

Individuals who were moved onto a reformed scheme in 2015, will now be treated as if they have remained in the legacy scheme and scheme administers must roll back any individuals with any remedial service into a legacy scheme. (those who accrued benefits before 31st March 2012).

 

What about my Tax position?

The standard annual pension allowance is available to all individuals, in which there is a maximum amount of tax-free growth your pension can grow by in a tax year.

If you have pensionable service in the remedy period that has been rolled back, your tax position may have changed, and you may have either paid too much annual allowance charge or not paid enough.

 

What can I do?

If you have a pension within the public sector and are affected by the roll back, your scheme provider will be re-calculating your pension amounts, and you will be receiving a ‘remediable pension savings statement.’ This will clarify your new scheme.

HMRC have confirmed that those affected will not need to resubmit any self-assessment tax returns as they have set up a specialised digital service in which members and those representing can correct their positions.

The service will allow individuals to make an application for a refund of any previously overpaid annual allowance charges for tax years 2019/20 up to and including 2021/22.

Individuals will also be able to claim compensation for any overpaid annual allowance charges for years 2015/16 to 2018/19.

Underpayments can also be paid for the tax years 2019/20, 2020/21 and 2021/22. The years before those are out of HMRC’s 4-year rule so therefor not included in any demands.

 

If you think you are affected by the Public Sector Pension Scheme reforms and are unsure of what to do next due to the complexity of the calculations, please contact the experts at Mr Tax in Blaby, Leicestershire, on 0116 2642585 – we’re here to offer our expertise and support to both existing and new clients.