The instruction I received was to help with an investigation case and as usual it came to me after the accountant had worked the case for some 22 months. The instruction was obtained from the taxpayer following a plea for help from the accountant.
The trap the accountant had fallen into was to let HMR&C dictate proceedings and to react. He replied to their correspondence rather than take the initiative. As the Inspector was only reviewing one year the accountant had given no thought to the overall strategy and had completely overlooked to find out when the defalcations had started and ended. To get a settlement the Inspector would have to complete his review of the one year and then he would have suggested using extrapolation both to adjust the earlier and subsequent years.
My approach was to find out what information was required, review it and then pass the required information on to the Inspector. I had established why the client started to understate profits and confirmed that he had stopped being so stupid. I then did the necessary work to prove that the funds available were sufficient to meet his living expenses. When I made a full submission to HMR&C the case was settled. What did I bring to the case? Very little or no tax saving. I got it settled and quickly which would have saved the client money in the overall settlement, i.e. both interest and penalty. Also I am sure that the professional fees were less than they would have been.
I have no idea how much stress I saved!